Go to Top

The Hidden Problem of Innovation Marketing

Innovation Marketing Takes Planning

…or You Can’t Solve a Problem until You Create One

Let’s just say you landed a job as the new CMO at a really great growth company. And not just any company. You just snagged a role at a really hot start-up.  Pre-IPO stock options.  In-house chef.  The works.

But wait―there’s more!  Your product (or service) is not an “also-ran” entry in an undifferentiated commodity market with nothing to talk about.  No, you’re marketing a true leading-edge product with demonstrable superiority.  A product (or service), they say, that practically “sells itself”.   You nailed it!

The Scariest Words in Innovation Marketing

That’s the good news.  But it’s also the bad news.  It means that you face seven real obstacles that your predecessor likely did not overcome:

  1. No one has identified the “situation” as a “problem to be fixed”.
  2. No one knows how much it is costing the company.
  3. No one person has the responsibility for managing it.
  4. No one has a budget for managing it.
  5. No one has it anywhere on their priority
  6. No one has successfully advocated for trying this new untried solution.
  7. And it’s likely no one wants to be the first to try.

Ironic, isn’t it?  The scariest words in marketing just might be “we have a product that sells itself.”

Come to think of it, why do you think that CMO position was open?  Unless you come up with another way to sell it, that “piece of cake” assignment just might be the “kiss of death!”

This is not a fantasy.  I recently worked with clients in three completely different industries, and each had superior solutions to real problems.  And each was stuck in the mud.

The problem was that, in their enthusiasm for their newly-found superior solution, they failed to own the solvable problem.  And identify who in the prospect company really suffered from it.  And who in the company had the budget to solve it.

They all were suffering from invisibility, that is, their prospects needed to see a problem that should and could be solved before they could see buying a solution. Until then, the “problem” was just a “fact of life,” like breathing, which leads me to a story… 

The Challenge of Selling Air

Innovation Marketing and Nothing

I bought a can of …nothing

I recently had the opportunity to hike Mt. Whitney, which at 14,505 feet is the highest peak in the contiguous US.  I was pretty excited about it…except that I know I get fairly severe altitude sickness (don’t ask).

So one of the things I was encouraged to bring was a can of oxygen. Yes, I bought a can of…nothing.

Except that at high altitude, nothing becomes something.  Something very important.  An invisible element we never think of becomes a vital ingredient.  Canned oxygen becomes the solution to altitude sickness.

To make the point even clearer, there was a label on the can advising me that, yes, the can is light, and yes, it does feel empty, but no, this is not an “empty” can of nothing because oxygen is light (you can imagine how many customer service calls led to that notice!).

In the context of my three clients, they each were focusing on promoting the solution of “canned oxygen” (who needs that?) rather than the problem of “altitude sickness” (I’ve got that!).

The First Big Problem of “Problem Marketing”

The first really big problem in true innovation marketing is naming and transforming the “fact of life” into a “problem you ought to solve”.  That means prospect education through four stages of “problem messaging:”

  1. The “condition” prospects face is, in fact, a costly problem that ought to be moved up their priority list.
  2. It is possible to reduce or eliminate the problem, and companies that do reap great rewards.
  3. The method for getting from #1 to #2 is exactly what our product does and why we started our company.
  4. There are proven ways for individual champions to advance this solution at prospect companies. We call this “champion marketing”.

The Second Problem Is Really the First

So, the first step in successfully selling a product that “sells itself” is selling the problem, not the solution.  But there is a problem in making problem marketing or innovation marketing your top priority.  It’s the company that hired you!  Oh, no!

Think about this.  Who are the people in all the world who have the hardest time seeing that the problem is invisible?  Right―it’s the founders of the very company that was formed to solve it!  They are the very people who first saw the problem clearly enough to invest in creating a solution!

This is tricky.  Everyone else in the company naturally is excited about getting the story out about their great new product!  Everyone else is an evangelist for how clear and compelling their solution is!

In fact, it’s not unusual to hear sales or engineering teams getting frustrated with prospects who are “too dumb” because they “can’t understand our product.”

And now the innovation marketing team is telling them they have to devote most of their energy to talking about the problem and not the solution?  I don’t think so! Maybe marketing doesn’t get it either!

So, you can see how this case becomes a fundamental cultural issue.  But if the innovation marketing team buys into the internal culture, they are dead.  That’s because the marketing team needs to be the conduit between “outside” people and “inside” people…without losing the connection with either.

Clearing the Air

The path to progress―and that successful IPO―is to address the two tasks of innovation marketing―or problem marketing―in the right order.  Make sure internal management buys into and supports the need to evangelize the problem before you can evangelize the solution.  And then walk prospects through the steps to seeing the invisible.  It will be a breath of fresh air.  And everyone―including you―will breathe a lot easier.

Innovation Marketing Might Start with "Clearing the Air"

MENG is the indispensable community of executive level marketers who share their passion and expertise to ensure each member’s success.
Learn moreApply for Membership

, , ,

About Wayne Cerullo

Wayne founded B2P Partners a dozen years ago to help B2B companies see past their products to their prospects with the vision of making B2B marketing more powerful by making it more personal. B2P has worked with mid-tier B2B growth firms as well as global leaders like Baxter, Citibank, IBM, Microsoft, Siemens, and Visa.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Show Buttons
Hide Buttons